Maria. A.
Garcia-Benau • Ana Zorio
Published online:
6 February 2013
International
Network of Business and Management 2013
Abstract This paper
analyses the current situation as regards entry requirements to the accounting
profession from an international perspective. Auditing is a public interest
service so it is regulated in different jurisdictions. Our results show that
even though this service is dominated by global multinational companies and
entry barriers to foreign markets seem to be falling, there is important
diversity among entry requirements to the audit profession in the countries
analysed. The authors support the need for international harmonization in this
field by means of promoting global acceptance of the standards set by the
International Accounting Education Standards Board from the International Federation
of Accountants. This paper is extremely timely given the fact that the Spanish
standard setter is about to make regulatory changes in this regard and has
created a discussion group to this end.
Keywords Auditing
Entry requirement IES IAESB
IFAC
Introduction
Access to the Spanish
Official Registry of Auditors (Registro Oficial de Auditores de Cuentas, ROAC)
was regulated by Law 19/1988 on the Statutory Auditing as well as by the
subsequent implementing regulations and by orders convening examinations and
some resolutions of the Instituto de Contabilidad y Auditorı´a de Cuentas
(ICAC), the Spanish accounting and auditing standard setter which depends from
the Ministry of Economics. There have recently been some changes in the
regulations that establish the requirements to become an auditor that have led
the
Maria. A.
Garcia-Benau A. Zorio (&)
Departament
de Comptabilitat, Universitat de Valencia, Valencia, Spain e-mail:
ana.zorio@uv.es
Maria.
A. Garcia-Benau e-mail: garciab@uv.es
Spanish
accounting standard-setter (ICAC) to create a think tank to propose amendments
to the current legislation on admittance to ROAC. We are referring to the
passing of Directive 2006/43/EC and Law
12/2011,1 amending Law
19/1988 on the Statutory Auditing.
The audit profession
has had to adopt changes in its methodology (Khalifa et al. 2007) and education (Armitage
2008; Allen and Woodland 2010; Crawford
et al. 2011; O’leary
2012) to face an increasingly complex business environment (Defond and Francis 2005),
which is becoming more and more global. The audit market is also dominated by
global players. Hence, from our point of view, it is very timely to analyse
whether there is consistency internationally as regards entry requirements to
this profession.
Therefore, this paper
has a twofold aim. We intend to analyse the current situation of entry to the
auditing profession in an international context and also to offer some
reflections on how to approach change in line with the globalised environment
in which the profession provides its services. In particular, we analyse the
situation of ten international benchmark countries to conclude that there is a
need to progress towards European and international harmonisation of entry
requirements to the auditing profession.
After highlighting the
reasons for this study in the above paragraphs, the second section summarises
the legal framework for auditor education and actions underway in ten
countries, six from the European Union and four non-European countries. In the
third section, we present the requirements for entry to the auditing profession
in Spain, emphasising the most controversial points in the debate. Finally, the
conclusions highlight the need to harmonise legal requirements of training and
education for entry to the auditing profession, bearing in mind that we live in
a globalised world.
Legal
framework
The audit supervision
model adopted by Europe is laid down by Directive 2006/43/
EC. This Directive maintains access to the auditing profession through the
‘‘academic route’’ and the ‘‘professional route’’ (with long-term practical
experi-ence, see Articles 6 and 11).
Under Article 6, a
person may carry out an audit only after ‘having attained university entrance or
equivalent level, then completed a course of theoretical instruction, undergone
practical training and passed an examination of professional competence of
university final or equivalent examination level’.
The examination of
professional competence guarantees the level of technical knowledge of
statutory audit subjects and the ability to put that knowledge into practice.
Article 8 in Directive 2006/43 lists the
subjects to be covered by a test of theoretical knowledge (Table 1).
1
In particular Article 7 on authorisation and registration in ROAC, that will
shortly be the object of implementing legislation.
Table 1 Subjects of theoretical knowledge to be
covered by the test
Financial
reporting subjects
(a)
General
accounting theory and principles;
(b)
Legal
requirements and standards relating to the preparation of annual and
consolidated accounts;
(c)
International
accounting standards;
(d)
Financial
analysis;
(e)
Cost
and management accounting;
(f)
Risk
management and internal control;
(g)
Auditing
and professional skills;
(h)
Legal
requirements and professional standards relating to statutory audit and
statutory auditors;
(i)
International
auditing standards;
(j)
Professional
ethics and independence.
Other related
subjects
(a)
Company
law and corporate governance;
(b)
The
law of insolvency and similar procedures;
(c)
Tax
law;
(d)
Civil
and commercial law;
(e)
Social
security law and employment law;
(f)
Information
technology and computer systems;
(g)
Business,
general and financial economics;
(h)
Mathematics
and statistics;
(i)
Basic
principles of the financial management of undertakings
According to Article 10
of the Directive, a trainee shall complete a minimum of 3 years’ practical
training in, inter alia, the auditing of annual accounts, consolidated accounts
or similar financial statements. At least two thirds of such practical training
shall be completed with a statutory auditor or audit firm approved in any
Member State. Member States shall ensure that all training is carried out with
persons providing adequate guarantees regarding their ability to provide
practical training.
We consider that in
addition to the above mentioned European Directive, other pronouncements should
also be considered such as the revised model of the UNCTAD-ISAR (2003) accounting syllabus, the Common Content
initiative supported by some European countries (see The Common Content Project
2010a, b, c, d, e) and even more importantly as a global reference,
the International Education Standards (IES)
issued by International Accounting Education Standards Board (IAESB) from the
International Federation of Accountants (IFAC) (IFAC 2010a).
In this regard, we
should also not lose sight of the harmonisation process that has led the
European Union though EC Regulation 1606/2002 to accept the International
Financial Reporting Standards issued by the International Accounting Standards
Board (IASB) for certain European enterprises (Garcia-Benau and Zorio 2004) and through Directive 2006/43/EC to propose the
adoption of the International Standard on Auditing (ISA) issued by the
International Auditing and Assurance Standards
Board from the IFAC.
These standards have been recently clarified (Zorio et al. 2010).
These European measures
have been proposed with the aim of progressing towards harmonising accounting
and auditing. Therefore, we consider that in the field of auditing, in addition
to ISA (technical standards), auditor training standards should be harmonised.
In our opinion, we need to gain further knowledge and valuation of the
suitability of IAESB standards that constitute training standards for entering
the auditing profession and for the necessary ongoing training of auditors (see
McPeak et al. 2012). IAESB standards will also
be clarified through a Clarity Project (IFAC 2010b).
In this paper, we present our opinion on whether these training standards
should at some point become the benchmark for the European Union, in particular
as regards the initial training of auditors.
For the purposes of this
study, the following eight IES and three International Education Practice
Statement (IEPS) published to date are of special interest.
IES 1: Entry
Requirements to a Program of Professional Accounting Education IES 2: Content
of Professional Accounting Education Programs
IES
3: Professional Skills and General
Education
IES
4: Professional Values, Ethics and Attitudes IES 5: Practical Experience
Requirements
IES
6: Assessment of Professional
Capabilities and Competence
IES 7: Continuing Professional
Development: a Program of Lifelong Learning and Continuing Development of
Professional Competence
IES
8: Competence Requirements for Audit
Professionals
IEPS 1: Approaches to Developing and
Maintaining Professional Values, Ethics, and Attitudes
IEPS
2: Information Technology for
Professional Accountants
IEPS 3: Practical Experience
Requirements—Initial Professional Development for Professional Accountants
A new aspect of these international
standards is the consideration of skills classified according to IES 3 into
intellectual, personal, interpersonal and communicative, organisational and
business world skills. All of them enable auditors to learn how to organise
information and analyse it critically; manage their daily individual activity
effectively, enabling them to manage their work efficiently and improve
relations with third parties.
We have analysed the
information provided by the IFAC in ten countries (Table 2) the national accounting bodies of which have provided
information in this field (see also Quick et al. 2008).
Appendix illustrate the differences with a comparative table.
France, Germany,
Ireland, Italy, the Netherlands and the United Kingdom as member countries of
the Common Content clearly support IES. The United Kingdom participates very
actively in IAESB. Ireland places great value on developing information
technology skills. Japan and USA have included IES in their regulations. Spain
has not incorporated them into its legislation. Canada and China want to
introduce IES; Canada in particular already follows IES on the valuation of
professional skills and competences (IES 6).
Theoretical training
for entering the auditing profession is highly valued in all countries and it
is regulated and specified in all of them, except for China where no particular
theoretical training is specified. In most countries, universities are
responsible for providing theoretical teaching, normally in the form of a
master’s degree course. In the United Kingdom, it is also possible to provide
theoretical training in some private teaching centres. Italy specifies that
universities providing training must be accredited.
Within the theoretical
training phase, the role of the Ministry of Education, professional
corporations and other bodies is often emphasised. For example, in Ireland and
Canada, the corporations themselves establish the requirements and collaborate
with the universities to produce the syllabus. In France, the requirements are
laid down by the Ministry of Education and the Conseil Supe´rieur de l’Ordre
des Expert-Comptables and the Compagnie Nationale des Commissaires aux Comptes
although there is an alternative aptitude test contemplated in IES. In Germany,
there are two-year Master’s degree courses oriented at practical training.
Theoretical training in Japan is in accordance with IES.
As regards practical
training, in Canada, at least 3 years’ practical experience is required, and 2
at senior level as in France where training must take place within a 5-year
period. Germany and Italy require 3 years’ work experience. China and Japan
require 2 years’ work experience; Japan considers that work experience can be
done before or after the examination, and also wants to introduce and unify the
figure of the mentor and propose strict monitoring and evaluation of the
practical experience that can be gained before, during or after the theoretical
training.
The figure of the work
experience mentor has been established in some countries. In France and the
United Kingdom, there is a system of controlled mentoring with an updated list
of authorised mentors and candidates in the process of practical training.
During this training period, trainee auditors must acquire diversified
experience in different areas of audit work. Ireland has a register of
activities and each candidate submits skills form signed and assessed by
his/her mentor that must be presented to the auditing corporation or body. In the
USA, there is no mentoring system, but each
candidate must present a report on his/her practical training. In China, there
is an authorised tutor for practical experience, but apparently no control or
monitoring of the practical work undertaken.
In many of the
countries, the entry test or examination is held on a regular basis. In Canada,
the United Kingdom and Germany, it is held every 6 months, whereas China,
France, Ireland and Japan hold one every year.
Some countries such as
Italy, France and Germany require that the applicants pass an oral test in
addition to the written test. In particular, in France, the written test is
case based and the oral test concerns the practical experience and discussion of
a topic; whereas in Italy, the oral part focuses on issues related to ethics
and professional values. However, other countries only have a written test such
as it is the case in Ireland, Spain, the United Kingdom and the United States.
As for the content of
the examination, it is worth emphasising that in Ireland, knowledge of the
International Standards on Auditing (ISA) has been a requirement since year
2009. In Italy, the contents of the test are defined in the legislation itself.
In Canada, the examination also has to assess competences and skills according
to IES 6.
Current
situation in Spain
Law 12/2010, on the
Statutory Auditing states that it is ‘a service provided to the audited entity
that affects and interests not only of that entity but also of third parties’.
Directive 2006/43/EC emphasises that audits facilitate ‘the orderly functioning
of markets by enhancing the integrity and efficiency of financial statements’.
The Green Paper (European Commission 2010;
Humphrey et al. 2011) adopts a similar
standpoint as it establishes that audit should be a key contributor to
financial stability. Indeed, auditing provides assurance on the veracity of the
financial health of companies. In particular, it points out that robust audit
is key to re-establishing market confidence. These considerations point to the
great signif-icance of audit in the current economic environment and in the
capital markets (Humphrey et al. 2009; Fogarty
and Rigsby 2010). It is therefore in the public
interest to suitably regulate access to the auditing profession.
Access to the profession
can only take place after a controlled stage of theoretical training and guided
practical training. These stages conclude with the sitting of an examination.
To date, in line with international pronouncements on entry requirements for
the auditing profession, Spain requires theoretical training, practical
training and the passing of an entry test.
Article 7 of Law
12/2010 on Auditing deals with the authorisation and registration with the ROAC
(the Official Spanish Registry of Auditors) and does not propose major changes
in the essential regulations for access to the auditing profession. To date,
universities and professional corporations have been relied upon to deliver the
required theoretical training. Practical preparation must ensure that auditors
have in-depth knowledge of their mission and are able to organise their work to
obtain the necessary evidence to form a professional opinion that will enable
them to draft and defend their audit reports. The aptitude examination
includes (a) an initial
theoretical part which may be dispensed provided the necessary knowledge has
been acquired at officially recognised centres and (b) a second practical part
that all candidates must take.
The presentation and
analysis of current requirements in Spain highlight some weak points, both
because of the time that has elapsed since the requirements were established
and in view of international statements. Below is a presentation of what we
believe the next reform of the system should include.
As regards the
theoretical training of auditors in the new context of new European High
Education Area, greater detail is required in the courses for the theoretical
training of candidates as official university qualifications now have a much
more flexible scheme. We consider that the definition of the curricular content
must be offered in ECTS credits as it would guarantee immediate comparability
in the European Union. The emphasis should be not only on the theoretical
knowledge demanded of trainee auditors but also on the skills necessary to
perform the audit (IES 3) and issues of ethics and independence (IES 4, IEPS
1). As a result, a need to produce complete teaching guides arises so as to
ensure a pedagogical approach to the courses and better monitoring of course
development and subsequent evaluation of the knowledge acquired.
Trainee auditors should
be given integral practical training. Adequate practical training could be
ensured by regulating the contractual link between the candidate and the
employer as well as defining the mentor’s work.
In this regard, it
would be advisable to ensure certain levels of commitment from mentors with the
candidates while also designing a due-process for monitoring the practical
experience. A record should be kept of all the tasks candidates learn and
perform with a view to complying with a well-defined experience syllabus. One
of the most interesting issues for developing the practical experience period
is the availability of good mentors. These mentors must offer the student
appropriate training and supervision.
And finally, there is a
need to reconsider whether access examinations should verify not only knowledge
but also skills. Good professional skills will surely enhance candidates’
ability to cope in the present business environment, which is why it is so
important that at the training stage trainees must learn these professional
skills under the supervision of a mentor.
Conclusions
One of the ideas
suggested by the analysis in this article on the entry requirements to the
auditing profession is that there are many similarities in the countries we
have analysed yet there are also interesting discrepancies. International
accounting literature on the differences between the Anglo-Saxon and the
Continental accounting systems can help us explain many of the differences
between countries, however, even though currently the European Union has
aligned its own accounting model with IASB standards and is promoting higher
harmonisation also in auditing through the use of the International Standards
on Auditing (by the IFAC).
Therefore, the main
conclusion of this paper is to support progress towards harmonisation in the
initial training and education of auditors to gradually converge the entry
requirements to become a statutory auditor. To date, harmonisation in the
auditing sector has been defined by Article 26 of the Directive that indicates
that ‘Member States shall require statutory auditors and audit firms to carry
out statutory audits in compliance with international auditing norms adopted by
the Commission. Member States may apply a national auditing standard as long as
the Commission has not adopted an international auditing standard covering the
same subject-matter’. This article of the Directive is a clear commitment on
the part of the European Union to IFAC auditing standards.
But, is there any point
in having internationally harmonised technical auditing standards (ISA) if
auditor training and education to entry in the profession has not been
harmonised? Theoretical training, years of practical experience and an aptitude
examination are dealt with by Member States regulations in the field. However,
specific details are missing on skills assessment, control over practical
training and content of entry examinations. Progress towards harmonisation in
this field, in our opinion, will be achieved more easily if adoption of IES and
IEPS issued by the International Auditing Education Standards Board (IAESB) of
the IFAC is encouraged. The debate over the initial training and education of
auditors is extremely important as it will facilitate the adaptation of audits
to their intended aims to defend the public interest. Also and not less
importantly, it will ensure uniform rules of access to the supply of audit
services at a global level. This convergence will undoubtedly provide higher
quality audits and a better definition of the rules of play in a global market.
Appendix
See
Table 3
Table 3 Comparative
table of entry requirements (adapted from the information provided to IFAC in
the framework of its Compliance Program for IFAC members and associates)
|
Countries
|
Skills
|
Theoretical
|
Practical
|
Is there a practical
|
Examination
|
|
|
consideration
|
training
|
training
|
experience mentor?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Germany
|
In line with
|
Universities
|
3 years register
|
There is a mentor
|
Six-monthly
|
|
|
IES
|
|
of activities
|
|
examination
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
with an oral
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
component
|
|
Canada
|
Wants to
|
Universities
|
Minimum
|
Wants to introduce
|
Six-monthly
|
|
|
introduce
|
and
|
3 years, 2 at
|
mentors
|
examination.
|
|
|
IES and
|
Corporations
|
senior level
|
|
Follows IES
|
|
|
IEPS
|
|
|
|
6
|
|
China
|
Going to
|
No specific
|
2 years with a
|
Authorised
tutor.
|
Yearly
|
|
|
introduce
|
training
|
Chinese audit
|
No control or
|
examination
|
|
|
IES
|
|
firm
|
monitoring.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Glob Bus Perspect (2013)
1:122–131
|
||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Table 3
continued
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Countries
|
Skills
|
Theoretical
|
Practical
|
Is there a practical
|
Examination
|
|
|
consideration
|
training
|
training
|
experience mentor?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Spain
|
Doesn’t
|
Universities
|
3 years, two
|
Doesn’t exist
|
Written
|
|
|
follow IES
|
and/or
|
with auditor
|
|
examination,
|
|
|
|
corporations
|
|
|
no
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
established
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
periodicity
|
|
USA
|
Follows IES
|
Universities.
|
1 or 2 years of
|
Doesn’t exist
|
Written
|
|
|
|
|
practice The
|
|
examination
|
|
|
|
|
candidate
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
produces a
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
report
|
|
|
|
France
|
Going to
|
Universities
|
3 years (2 at
|
Authorised mentors
|
Yearly
|
|
|
introduce
|
together with
|
least with an
|
|
examination
|
|
|
IES
|
the Ministry
|
auditor)
|
|
with a
written
|
|
|
|
of Education
|
Candidates
|
|
and oral part
|
|
|
|
and CSOEC
|
acquire
|
|
|
|
|
|
and CNCC
|
diversified
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
experience
|
|
|
|
Ireland
|
Syllabuses
|
Universities
|
3 years in
|
A mentor evaluates
|
Annual written
|
|
|
are
|
and/or
|
specific areas
|
the activities and
|
examination
|
|
|
reviewed
|
corporations
|
|
presents it to the
|
|
|
|
according
|
|
|
corporation
|
|
|
|
to IES
|
|
|
|
|
|
Italy
|
IES taken
|
Universities
|
3 years
|
n/a
|
Written and
|
|
|
into
|
together with
|
|
|
oral
|
|
|
account
|
corporations
|
|
|
component
|
|
Japan
|
Follows IES
|
Course by the
|
Minimum
|
n/a
|
Annual
|
|
|
|
corporation
|
2 years in an
|
|
|
|
|
|
for those who
|
audit firm
|
|
|
|
|
|
pass the CPA
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
examination
|
|
|
|
|
United
|
Follows IES
|
Universities
|
n/a
|
The mentor
|
Six-monthly
|
|
Kingdom
|
|
and other
|
|
registers the
|
written
|
|
|
|
private
|
|
activities and
|
examination
|
|
|
|
teaching
|
|
evaluates them in
|
on case
|
|
|
|
bodies
|
|
a report which is
|
studies.
|
|
|
|
|
|
sent to the
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
corporation.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar